Case Study

January 6, 2021 / 5 minute read

Rebuilding Paradise Using HDPE ADS Pipe

First published in Civil + Structural Engineer, January 2021

Paradise

The rebuilding of the town here that was destroyed by the Camp Fire continues  with  a  focus  on  the  rapid  replacement  of  water  service  lines. “When  we’re  done,  there  will  be  about  315,000  feet  of  new  HDPE  service  lines,”  stated  Kevin  Phillips,  Town  Manager  for  the  Town of Paradise.

Prior to the 2018 fire, the town had a population of 26,000.  During 17 days starting on November 8, 2018, the fire destroyed some 150,000 acres and nearly 19,000 homes and buildings. 

The Paradise Irrigation Department is replacing all water service lines using high-density polyethylene (HDPE) PE 4710 pipe in diameters of one  to  two inches.    The  pipe,  PolyFlex™  CTS  potable  water  service  tubing from Advanced Drainage Systems, Inc. (ADS) (NYSE: WMS), is resistant to rot and corrosion, can be easily installed and is consistent with industry specifications for potable water.

“This  SDR  9  PolyFlex  tubing  from  ADS  is  produced  in  accordance  with AWWA Standard C901, and meets NSF 14 and 61 standards,” explained Camille George Rubeiz, P.E., F. ASCE, co-chair, HDPE Mu-nicipal Advisory Board and senior director of engineering, Municipal and Industrial Division of the Plastics Pipe Institute, Inc. (PPI).  “This means that the pipe is certified for potable water systems because it meets or exceeds the requirements for health effects in drinking water components, and also the performance criteria of plastic piping com-ponents as stipulated by NSF.  PE 4710 compounds offer an excellent level  of  performance  for  trenchless  and  open  cut  installations. The PE 4710 HDPE pipe can be used with increased flow capacities plus increased  resistance  to  surge  events  and  fatigue. The ANSI/AWWA C906-15 standard includes PE 4710 for sizes up to 65 inches and rec-ognizes the increased durability and reliability of HDPE pressure pipe used in water systems."

After the fire, accusations were made that sections of burnt plastic pipe found  above  ground  created  benzene,  which  found  its  way  into  the  Paradise  water  system.    The  Plastics  Pipe  Institute,  the  major  North  American trade association, investigated. 

“These  claims  are  patently  false,”  stated  David  Fink,  PPI  president.    “There has been no evidence that plastic pipes are responsible for the production  of  benzene  or  any  other  contaminant  due  to  the  heating  of  the  pipes  during  the  Camp  Fire.    It’s  clear  that  the  contamination  was from the millions of tons of the fire-ravaged environment that got sucked into the water system.”   

According to Phillips, “What the district saw was that the contamina-tion from the fire was not associated with any particular pipe material and that even the galvanized and copper pipes that were in the ground saw the same amount of contamination as the polyethylene.  There was a similar percentage of contaminated service laterals with those other materials as there was with polyethylene.  So, we decided to continue to use polyethylene because of the ease of use and the cost being the best on the market.  We felt it would be the best choice for the rebuild-ing of Paradise.

“This town was built during many, many decades.  When they first started building it, the pipes in the ground were actually lead.  During the  boom  in  the  1950s,  most  of  the  pipes  that  went  into  the  ground  were galvanized steel.  There were issues with corrosion so the district moved to copper pipe which, at that time, was the industry standard.  Again, there were flexibility and corrosion issues especially with the acidic soil conditions.  And so, the district finally moved to polyethylene because of the durability and made that our standard.  We felt it would be in the ground for many, many years.  Even after the fires, we found the buried polyethylene was undamaged from direct contact with heat.   The issue we found was contamination in the majority of service laterals which served burned structures, regardless of material type, so we needed to replace those service lines.  It (the HDPE pipe) also gave us the ability to come back and upsize those service lines to support the rebuild and meet with customers’ requirements for their meters and fire service.  PE seems to be the best product to meet those needs. Seismically, it’s flexible and can handle the movement up here.  It’s easy to pull in trenchless which makes it beneficial for the rebuild process.

“We felt the best form of protection for our service laterals was not the material itself but just putting in backflow protection to reduce the chance of contamination entering the system during a depressurization event.  Again, we believe the occurrence of contamination wasn’t associated with  the material of the piping, it was associated with the depressurization, contamination being drawn into the system and how long the system was disconnected to allow that contamination to ad-sorb into the pipe walls.”

Phillips estimates that the new Town of Paradise will take nearly 20 years to be back to where it was prior to the Camp Fire. 

“It takes a long time to build homes,” he said.  “We have had a huge surge of building permits issued in the Town of Paradise.  There is a ton of pressure on getting new water service to those new rebuilds.  And with polyethylene, it has created efficiencies so that we can get out there and get a service line in within an hour or two of that request.  Once we get there and onsite it’s very easy to get in that water line because of the use of polyethylene.

“By use of the polyethylene and the ability for us to get it in without a lot of problems and be able to get it in the street and work around issues that might be there, such as rocks and other services that are coming underground.  It makes the rebuild process and getting the water service back a lot easier than it would be if we had to bore through with a steel or copper (pipe).  PE is our standard moving forward and throughout the rebuild process.”

Additionally, large diameter N-12® corrugated HDPE pipe from ADS is being used on several stormwater drainage projects in Paradise.  These include the Paradise tennis courts and the Paradise softball field.   

As a service to the industry, the PPI recently published its analysis of benzene contamination found at the site of the 2018 Camp Fire catas-trophe in and around Paradise.